NearbyON Sign in

Hiring a contractor in New Jersey: red flags and questions to ask

Most pros are honest and good at what they do. These warning signs, questions and New Jersey rules help you spot the few who aren’t, before you pay a cent.

7 min read

A model house on top of house plans, with a magnifying glass and a piggy bank

7 red flags

  1. They want more than a third of the price before starting. New Jersey’s Division of Consumer Affairs warns about it.
  2. They “were in the neighborhood”. A contractor who shows up at your door uninvited is on Consumer Affairs’ list of warning signs too.
  3. Cash only. Pay in a way that leaves a record.
  4. Only a P.O. box. A contractor you can’t find at a real address is hard to hold to a contract.
  5. No HIC number. The 13VH number must be on ads, contracts and vehicles. Ask for it and look it up.
  6. They ask for the final payment, or a signed certificate of completion, before the job is done. They’re not allowed to.
  7. They offer to handle your insurance claim. Negotiating a claim for pay takes a public adjuster license.

6 questions to ask before you sign

  1. “What’s your HIC number?” And for plumbing, electrical or HVAC work, the license of the plumber, electrician or HVACR contractor. Then check them.
  2. “Can I have a copy of your insurance?” Registered contractors must carry at least $500,000 of liability insurance per occurrence, and a contract over $500 must include a copy of the certificate.
  3. “Who pulls the permit?” It should be the contractor. An unregistered contractor can’t get one, and plumbing, electrical and HVAC permit applications carry the licensee’s seal and signature.
  4. “Who are your subcontractors and suppliers?” You can ask for the list in writing, and the contractor must give it to you within 10 days.
  5. “How much up front, and when do I pay the rest?” Pay in stages, and inspect the work before the last payment.
  6. “Can I get every promise in writing?” Verbal guarantees and promises should be written into the contract.

A good pro answers all six without blinking. If someone gets annoyed by these questions, that’s an answer too.

What New Jersey law gives you

  • A written contract over $500. It must have the contractor’s legal name, business address and registration number, a copy of the insurance certificate and the total price. It should also describe the work and the materials, and give the dates the work starts and ends.
  • Three business days to cancel, for any reason. You can cancel a home improvement contract until midnight of the third business day after you get your copy. Do it in writing, by certified or registered mail with a return receipt, or in person. Your money comes back within 30 days.
  • Permits that fit the job. Ordinary maintenance needs no permit: painting, flooring, siding, replacing windows, doors or a garage door in the same opening, or re-covering the roof of a detached one- or two-family home. Swapping a water heater, furnace, boiler or A/C for a similar one is “minor work”: it needs a permit, but can start once the building office is told. Fences up to 6 feet need no permit, except around a pool.
  • Licensed trades only. Plumbing, electrical and HVAC work must be done by licensed pros, except by an owner in the single-family home they live in.
  • Lead-safe work in older homes. If your home was built before 1978, a paid job that disturbs old paint needs an EPA-certified renovation firm. In New Jersey, the EPA runs that program. Permanent lead removal needs a firm certified by the Department of Community Affairs.
  • 811 before digging. Whoever digs must call 811 at least 3, and no more than 10, business days ahead. Removing a tree or its roots and setting fence posts count as digging.

Don’t pay twice: liens and the last payment

New Jersey protects homeowners from surprise liens. Before a contractor can file a lien on your home, they must file a Notice of Unpaid Balance within 60 days of their last work and go through arbitration. Three habits keep you safe:

  • Know your limit. A lien can’t be more than what you still owe under your contract.
  • Ask for the list of subcontractors and suppliers, and for lien waivers from them when you pay.
  • Before the last payment, walk through the job and check everything that was promised.

Need a pro for this?

Tell us what you need and see local pros near you, with photos of their work. Then message them on WhatsApp. Free, no sign-up.

Sources

  1. NJ Division of Consumer Affairs: hiring home improvement contractors (PDF)
  2. NJ Division of Consumer Affairs: home improvement contractors FAQ
  3. N.J.S.A. 56:8-151: the written contract and the 3 days to cancel
  4. N.J.S.A. 56:8-142: the insurance a registered contractor needs
  5. Mercer County Consumer Affairs: home improvement contracts
  6. New Jersey Uniform Construction Code: when a permit is needed (PDF)
  7. N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-21: liens on homes and the Notice of Unpaid Balance
  8. N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-9: a lien is limited to what the owner still owes
  9. N.J.S.A. 2A:44A-37: the list of subcontractors and suppliers
  10. N.J.S.A. 17:22B-2: public adjusters
  11. N.J.S.A. 48:2-82: call 811 before you dig
  12. U.S. EPA: lead renovation, repair and painting program
  13. NJ Department of Community Affairs: lead abatement

This guide is general information, not legal or professional advice. Rules change, so check the sources and ask a licensed pro about your home.