Hiring a contractor in Massachusetts: red flags and questions to ask
Most pros are honest and good at what they do. These warning signs, questions and Massachusetts rules help you spot the few who aren’t, before you pay a cent.

7 red flags
- A deposit of more than a third of the price. Massachusetts law caps it at one-third, or the cost of special-order materials if that’s more.
- “You pull the permit.” The contractor is responsible for the permits. If you get the building permit yourself, you may not be eligible for the state’s Guaranty Fund or its arbitration program.
- No HIC number on the contract or the ads. Ask for it and look it up.
- A contract with blank spaces. Massachusetts contracts must say, right above the signature: “Do not sign this contract if there are any blank spaces.”
- They knocked on your door and want to start today. For a sale made at your home, you have three business days to cancel, and the seller can’t start the work during that time.
- They want the final payment before the job is finished. The law says it waits until the work is done to the satisfaction of both of you.
- No written contract. It’s required for any home improvement job over $1,000.
6 questions to ask before you sign
- “What’s your HIC number, and who will supervise the job?” Then check the registration and the supervisor’s license.
- “Who pulls the permit?” It should be the contractor. Post the permit card at the job until the work is done.
- “Is your crew covered by workers’ compensation?” Every employer in Massachusetts must have it, whatever the number of employees. Ask for the certificate.
- “Are you a licensed lead-safe renovation contractor?” If your home was built before 1978, you need one for most paid jobs that disturb old paint, and for any window replacement.
- “What’s the payment schedule?” The contract must spell it out in dollars. Tie each payment to work that’s done.
- “Will you give me lien waivers when I pay?” On bigger jobs, ask for them from the contractor, the subcontractors and the suppliers.
A good pro answers all six without blinking. If someone gets annoyed by these questions, that’s an answer too.
What Massachusetts law gives you
- A written contract over $1,000. It must include the start and completion dates, a detailed description of the work and the materials, the total price and the payment schedule, the contractor’s registration number, and a notice of your right to cancel. The contractor must tell you which permits the job needs and that getting them is the contractor’s job.
- Three business days to cancel a sale made at your home. For sales over $25, you can cancel in writing until midnight of the third business day, and the seller can’t start the work in that time.
- Arbitration and the Guaranty Fund. Registered contractors must agree to the state’s arbitration program. If you win in court or in arbitration and a registered contractor doesn’t pay, the Guaranty Fund may pay up to $25,000 of your actual loss. Neither covers unregistered contractors.
- A licensed supervisor for permitted work. Work that needs a building permit must be supervised by someone with a construction supervisor license, and the permit application carries the HIC number.
- Lead-safe work in older homes. In homes built before 1978, a paid job that disturbs more than 6 square feet of paint in a room or 20 square feet outside, any window replacement or any demolition needs a contractor licensed by the Department of Labor Standards, who gives you the Renovate Right pamphlet. If a child under 6 lives in the home, the state’s Lead Law asks for more.
- Dig Safe before digging. Whoever digs must call 811 at least 72 business hours ahead and mark the area in white, even for a mailbox post. The contractor needs a ticket of its own.
Don’t pay twice: liens and the last payment
In Massachusetts, a contractor, subcontractor or supplier with a written contract can record a lien notice at the registry of deeds, generally within 90 days after the last work. Three habits keep you safe:
- Pay only as the work gets done, and keep a record of every payment.
- Ask for lien waivers when you pay. A clause that bans liens isn’t valid, but waivers in the form the law sets are.
- Know your limit. A subcontractor’s lien can’t be more than what you still owed your contractor when the notice was recorded.
Need a pro for this?
Tell us what you need and see local pros near you, with photos of their work. Then message them on WhatsApp. Free, no sign-up.
Sources
- Mass.gov: home improvement contractor (HIC) resources for homeowners
- M.G.L. c.142A §2: what a home improvement contract must say
- M.G.L. c.142A §14: who doesn’t need to register
- Mass.gov: is the home improvement arbitration program right for you?
- M.G.L. c.93 §48: canceling a sale made at home
- Mass.gov: workers’ compensation insurance requirements
- Mass.gov: the construction supervisor licenses
- Mass.gov: lead-safe renovation
- Mass.gov: the Massachusetts Lead Law
- Mass.gov: about Dig Safe
- M.G.L. c.254 §2: liens on homes
This guide is general information, not legal or professional advice. Rules change, so check the sources and ask a licensed pro about your home.
